Most new executives can tell you, in detail, everything that’s competing for their attention. Fewer can tell you, honestly, what actually matters most.

It’s not that the leader is confused about the work. It’s that everything genuinely feels urgent, and there’s no longer anyone in the room who can push back on that feeling. The team below them needs direction. The board above them wants results. And the person at the center of it has stopped having real peers to think out loud with, which means every demand arrives with the same volume: loud.

The Real Cost Is Distorted Judgment

Isolation at the top doesn’t always look like isolation. It often looks like busyness, like a leader who’s clearly working hard and clearly in demand. What it produces is a subtle distortion: without anyone to pressure-test their thinking, leaders lose the ability to tell their genuinely critical priorities apart from everything else competing for their attention.

The fix isn’t more hours or more meetings, both of which can lead to burnout. It’s someone who can ask the question a peer would ask if the leader still had peers: what actually matters most here, and what are you telling yourself that isn’t quite true?

Someone Who Gets Underneath the Surface Issue

Jay Coughlin, one of Churchill’s Advisor Coaches, has built his approach around exactly that gap. His opening question with a new CEO is rarely tactical, closer to: What are you thinking about at three in the morning, because I know you’re up. That question gets past the facade every executive learns to maintain, straight to the fears and doubts nobody else is allowed to see.

One case makes the pattern concrete: A leader had just taken over a company worth several billion dollars, and Jay asked him a simple question: What are your top three priorities? He answered with fifteen.

Jay pushed back. Fifteen isn’t three. And the math mattered: if the leader executed brilliantly on priorities 7–9 but never landed 1, 2, and 3, the effort wouldn’t be enough to save him. Getting to an honest three took real work, and real discomfort. But the leader later came back and thanked him for it, because the clarity he’d been missing wasn’t just his own problem. The rest of the organization needed it too.

Jay sat down with Churchill CEO Jayne Jenkins to talk through what isolation actually costs leaders, and how advising gets underneath it. Watch their full conversation above.

Struggling to get your own priorities down to a number you could actually defend? Reach out to talk to Jay or Jayne about where to start.

What This Means for You

If you’re leading at a level where people increasingly report to you rather than think alongside you, it’s worth asking whether your list of priorities has quietly grown past the number you could actually defend under pressure. Isolation doesn’t announce itself. It just shows up as more things feeling equally urgent than actually are.

The leaders who catch this early aren’t the ones who work harder. They’re the ones who found someone willing to ask what they’ve stopped asking themselves.

Ready to talk?

Whether you’re navigating change, developing leaders or strengthening your culture, Churchill Leadership Group is here to help. Let’s explore how coaching and leadership development can support your organization’s goals.

More Ideas & Insights:

Sign up for our newsletter

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Opt In

Categories